Chat Transcript Analysis: Librarians vs. Student Assistants


Presented by:

Goebel Poster File

Click on the thumbnail
above to view the poster file.

Click on the Play (►) button below to listen to the audio narration:

  • Vera Lux, Bowling Green State University
  • Linda Rich, Bowling Green State University


How effective are student reference assistants at answering chat reference questions as compared to professional librarians? That’s the question we were asking ourselves at Bowling Green State University when we realized that a high percent of our chat reference questions were research based. Should we be letting our student assistants staff this service? To help us answer these questions, we evaluated 150 chat reference transcripts using a 13 question rubric. Our analysis indicated that librarians generally did a better job than student assistants answering chat reference questions, especially when it came to research based questions, but we also determined our undergraduate student assistants to be quite competent chat reference service providers! In some evaluative areas (i.e. building rapport and closing statements), student assistants scored as well, or nearly as well, as librarians; however, we also identified areas (i.e. completeness of answer & appropriate referrals) where additional training is needed.


Posted in 2015 Virtual Poster Session and tagged , , , .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *